(905) 415-1636

DJ, Pauly D, seeks sole custody after one night fling

We were all shocked and somewhat horrified to learn that Nicole Polizzi,
aka Snookie, the 4’10” binge drinking, no underwear wearing star
of Jersey Shore, was having a child with on-again, off-again boyfriend,
Jionni LaValle. Now, it appears there’s a second Shore baby.

Fist pumping resident DJ, Pauly D, is apparently a baby-daddy. According
to TMZ online, in the summer of 2012, the Las Vegas DJ impregnated Amanda
Market, 25, one night after partying at the Rehab pool party at the Hard
Rock Hotel.

And while I’m sure we’d all love to see a Jersey Shore: Second
Generation spinoff, this story is nevertheless troubling given the parties
apparent hatred for one another.

Earlier this week, Pauly D told TMZ that he was “proud [he’s]
a father” and is “excited to embark on this new part of [his]
life.”

But the good news ends there… Pauly D is now claiming that Market is
unfit to be a mother, pointing to her former employment at Hooters and
the fact that she is only 25 and is already a second-time mother. Apparently,
the jet setting DJ, famous for his partying ways and for coining the term
“grenade” to refer to unattractive women, thinks he will be
the better parent and role model to his young daughter.

TMZ now reports that both parties have filed court documents; Market is
seeking child support, while Pauly is seeking full legal custody of the
child that he’s never met.

So far, however, the parties can’t even decide on the appropriate jurisdiction.
While Market is a resident of New Jersey, Pauly D currently resides in
Nevada. The Jersey star is now claiming that it is inconvenient for him
to travel to Jersey every time there is a court appearance (although one
might assume it would be equally inconvenient for Market to travel to
Nevada). Some are speculating, however, that the reason for the contentious
battle over jurisdiction may be more complex. Apparently, there is a presumption
that parties share joint custody in Nevada, whereas no such presumption
exists in New Jersey.

And Mr. D doesn’t even seemed bothered by the fact that the child support
order would likely be higher if he were to be awarded joint custody in
Nevada. According to sources, the new father is more preoccupied with
getting custody than paying support.

In Ontario, the jurisdiction of the court is decided by the “habitual
residence” of the child. s. 22 of the
Children’s Law Reform Act (CLRA) establishes two alternate bases whereby an Ontario court may be found
to have jurisdiction to make an order in respect of custody or access.
First,) the child is “habitually resident” in Ontario. Second,
the child is in Ontario, there is substantial evidence concerning the
best interest of the child in Ontario, and there are no outstanding applications
where the child is habitually resident or foreign orders. , The child
has a real and substantial connection with Ontario, and the balance of
convenience favours Ontario.

While the laws regarding jurisdiction are undoubtedly different in the
United States, the fact that the child has only lived with Market in New
Jersey thus far, means that New Jersey likely has jurisdiction in this matter.

More From the Feldstein Blog

Ontario Family Law, Translated

The statute is dense. The stakes are personal. These articles unpack the parts clients ask about most.

Case Blog

R-S v. S., 2025 ONSC 6737

Background The Respondent husband and Applicant wife were married in 2013 and separated in 2022. One day before the wedding, each party signed different versions of a marriage ... Read more

June 26, 2026 · 6 min read

Feldstein Family Law Group, P.C.

The Law Is Complex.
The First Step Isn't.

Free, confidential consultation with an experienced Ontario family law lawyer. One call can change everything.

Markham · Oakville · Mississauga · Vaughan

Call (905) 415-1636

Responses within one business day — often the same day.

Our Offices

Serving Families Across Ontario & the Greater Toronto Area

Four Feldstein Family Law Group offices across the GTA — close to where our clients live, work, and raise their families.

Markham

20 Crown Steel Dr Suite 8
Markham, ON L3R 9X9, Canada

Map & Directions

Mississauga

3464 Semenyk Ct Suite 213
Mississauga, ON L5C 4P8, Canada

Map & Directions

Vaughan

3865 Major MacKenzie Dr W Suite 107
Vaughan, ON L4H 4P4, Canada

Map & Directions

Oakville

209 Speers Rd Suite 5
Oakville, ON L6K 0H5, Canada

Map & Directions

Communities We Serve

Feldstein Family Law Group represents clients across the Greater Toronto Area — including Toronto, Markham, Oakville, Mississauga, Vaughan, Richmond Hill, Thornhill, Unionville, Stouffville, Aurora, Newmarket, Brampton, Etobicoke, North York, Scarborough, Burlington, Milton, Georgetown, Woodbridge, Maple, King City, and the surrounding communities of York Region, Peel Region, Halton Region, and Durham Region.