(905) 415-1636

Simon Cowell Criticized for Affair, Pregnancy that led to Close Friend’s Divorce

While Simon Cowell may be well-known for his blunt criticism as a judge
on American Idol and The X Factor, he is now the subject of harsh judgment
for his role in the breakup of his close friend Andrew Silverman’s
10-year marriage.

Andrew, a wealthy real estate mogul and co-owner of Panama’s Veneto
Hotel & Casino, has filed for divorce, citing adultery as the reason
for the marital breakdown. Simon and Andrew’s estranged wife, Lauren
Silverman, have reportedly been having an affair since 2009. The reality
television star met Lauren, a New York socialite, in 2004, but the disloyal
duo didn’t become romantically involved until five years later.

A mere affair is not where this scandal ends, though – Lauren is also reportedly
10-weeks pregnant with Cowell’s first child, due in February 2014.

Although the Silvermans’ marriage was certainly not perfect, divorce
papers were never filed until Andrew learned of his wife’s affair.
In the divorce papers, Andrew stated, “The nature of this action
is: to dissolve the marriage between the parties based upon (1) the commission
of acts of adultery by the defendant and (2) defendant’s cruel and
inhuman treatment of the plaintiff.”

Soon after the scandal became public, Simon left for a vacation in St.
Tropez without Lauren. It is unclear at this time whether the couple intends to marry.

Here are some issues we can expect to see unravel as this matter progresses:

  1. Although Simon is reportedly trying to distance himself from the court
    battle, Andrew’s divorce documents list Simon as a co-respondent.
    This means Simon could be called to the witness stand.
  2. In New York, when adultery is proven, the court can force the cheating
    party (and Simon) to take a DNA test.
  3. Andrew is currently seeking full custody of the 7-year-old son he shares
    with Lauren. He is reportedly willing to settle custody and financial
    issues quickly in an effort to cut his ties to Lauren and Cowell as soon
    as possible.
  4. What may be the most controversial element of this divorce is the prenuptial
    agreement signed in 2003 by the now-estranged couple. The contract apparently
    states that Lauren is entitled to a $4-million settlement if she and Andrew
    were married 10 years. However, one source reports that Andrew did not
    discover Lauren’s affair until after their 10-year wedding anniversary.

More From the Feldstein Blog

Ontario Family Law, Translated

The statute is dense. The stakes are personal. These articles unpack the parts clients ask about most.

Case Blog

R-S v. S., 2025 ONSC 6737

Background The Respondent husband and Applicant wife were married in 2013 and separated in 2022. One day before the wedding, each party signed different versions of a marriage ... Read more

June 26, 2026 · 6 min read

Feldstein Family Law Group, P.C.

The Law Is Complex.
The First Step Isn't.

Free, confidential consultation with an experienced Ontario family law lawyer. One call can change everything.

Markham · Oakville · Mississauga · Vaughan

Call (905) 415-1636

Responses within one business day — often the same day.

Our Offices

Serving Families Across Ontario & the Greater Toronto Area

Four Feldstein Family Law Group offices across the GTA — close to where our clients live, work, and raise their families.

Markham

20 Crown Steel Dr Suite 8
Markham, ON L3R 9X9, Canada

Map & Directions

Mississauga

3464 Semenyk Ct Suite 213
Mississauga, ON L5C 4P8, Canada

Map & Directions

Vaughan

3865 Major MacKenzie Dr W Suite 107
Vaughan, ON L4H 4P4, Canada

Map & Directions

Oakville

209 Speers Rd Suite 5
Oakville, ON L6K 0H5, Canada

Map & Directions

Communities We Serve

Feldstein Family Law Group represents clients across the Greater Toronto Area — including Toronto, Markham, Oakville, Mississauga, Vaughan, Richmond Hill, Thornhill, Unionville, Stouffville, Aurora, Newmarket, Brampton, Etobicoke, North York, Scarborough, Burlington, Milton, Georgetown, Woodbridge, Maple, King City, and the surrounding communities of York Region, Peel Region, Halton Region, and Durham Region.