BACKGROUND
The Applicant appealed child support and property division orders made following a family law trial. The trial judge made significant adverse credibility findings against the Applicant, including finding that he had attempted to mislead the court regarding his assets. In contrast, the trial judge preferred the evidence of the Respondent, relying on documentary evidence and testimony from multiple witnesses.
The Applicant challenged several findings, including the duration of child support payable for the parties’ adult son, the treatment of a property held in trust for the Respondent’s father, the timing and value of the Applicant’s interest in a restaurant, and the treatment of Iranian properties in the net family property calculation.
ANALYSIS AND THE LAW
Appellate Deference to Findings of Fact
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, emphasizing that the Applicant’s submissions largely sought to revisit factual findings and credibility assessments made by the trial judge. Although the Applicant maintained that he was challenging the sufficiency of the evidence rather than simply rearguing the case, the Court found that his arguments ultimately invited it to substitute its own factual conclusions for those of the trial judge.
The Court reiterated that appellate intervention is not warranted absent a palpable and overriding error. The trial judge had the benefit of extensive documentary evidence, witness testimony, and the opportunity to assess the parties’ credibility firsthand. The record filed on appeal was also incomplete and insufficient to establish the alleged errors.
Child Support for an Adult Child
The Applicant argued that there was insufficient evidence to support the order requiring him to pay child support for the parties’ adult son until June 1, 2025.
The Court rejected this argument. The trial judge was entitled to rely on the Respondent’s testimony that their son’s studies would continue throughout the 2025 school year. The fact that the Respondent had previously anticipated that his studies would be completed earlier did not require the trial judge to reject her trial testimony.
The Court also upheld the selection of June 1, 2025, as the termination date for support. In the absence of evidence establishing the precise date on which the son would complete his studies, the trial judge reasonably selected a common termination date for college programs.
Property Ownership and Equalization
The Applicant also challenged the trial judge’s findings concerning the parties’ property interests.
First, the Court upheld the finding that the Vaughan Road property was subject to a purchase money resulting trust in favour of the Respondent’s father. The Applicant disputed the evidence concerning the source of the funds used for the down payment, but the Court found that these submissions amounted to an attempt to have the trial judge’s factual inferences reconsidered.
Second, the Court rejected the Applicant’s challenge to the finding that he acquired an interest in the Chamsine Restaurant before separation. The Applicant’s argument that funds obtained from the sale of the matrimonial home after separation had been used to pay debts did not establish that those funds had financed the restaurant purchase.
The Court further rejected the Applicant’s arguments concerning the valuation of his restaurant interest, the Respondent’s business, a reimbursement from his bank account, and the treatment of Iranian properties in the net family property calculation. The trial judge’s findings were supported by the evidence, and the Applicant had not demonstrated a palpable and overriding error.
CONCLUSION
The appeal is dismissed.
Attention Legal Counsel: Professional Mediation Services
When your clients have reached an impasse in settlement discussions, Andrew Feldstein offers third-party mediation services specifically designed for cases where both parties have independent legal representation.
Why lawyers refer cases to Andrew:
- 30+ years family law litigation experience providing courtroom-informed reality testing
- Expertise in complex financial matters including business valuations and professional corporations
- Efficient, structured process that respects counsel’s time and maintains client relationships
- Flexible scheduling including virtual mediation and travel to counsel offices
Cases we handle: Negotiation stalemates, complex asset division, support calculation disputes, parenting arrangements, multi-jurisdictional matters, and post-separation modifications.
Refer your next mediation: Call Andrew directly at 905-415-1635 ext. 255 or email info@separation.ca. Virtual and in-person sessions available throughout the GTA.
Need Help Moving a Family Law Matter Forward?
Whether you are a lawyer seeking an experienced mediator or you are representing yourself and need legal advice, our family law team can help you understand the options and identify a practical next step.
How We Help
Mediation, negotiation, litigation, complex financial disputes, support, property division, and parenting matters. Virtual and in-person appointments are available throughout the GTA.